| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1955 SLG 12 1955 SLD 12 1955 PLD 288 |
Lahore High Court
Regular First Appeal No. 12 of 1951, decided on 11th January 1955, from the decree of the Court of Muhammad Aslam Khan, Senior Civil Judge, Lahore, dated the 7th November 1950
M. R. KAYAHI AND AKHLAQUE HUSAIN, JJ
Muhammad Fazil and Kh. Nazir Ahmad, for Appellants. Sh. Bashir Ahmad, for
Respondent
Regular First Appeal No. 12 of 1951, decided on 11th January 1955, from the decree of the Court of Muhammad Aslam Khan, Senior Civil Judge, Lahore, dated the 7th November 1950
M. R. KAYAHI AND AKHLAQUE HUSAIN, JJ
Muhammad Fazil and Kh. Nazir Ahmad, for Appellants. Sh. Bashir Ahmad, for
Respondent
Lala KRISHAN LALL MALHOTRA and 2 others
VS
Sheikh MUHAMMAD SADIQ
Law: Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, (VI of 1947)
Section: 8,6,7
Law: Limitation Act, 1908
Section: 29
(a) Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act (VI of 1947), S. 8-Provides period of limitation (6 months) within which overpaid sums be recovered by tenant from landlord-Limitation Act (IX of 1908), S. 29-Special period of limitation excludes application of Art. 120, Limitation Act. Section 8, Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act (VI of 1947) provides the periods of limitation within which sums which have been made irrecoverable by the Act may be recovered. Neither Article 120 nor any other in the Limitation Act is applicable to a suit for recovery of such sums in view of the provisions of section 29 of that Act. The Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, is a special as well as a local law within the meaning of section 29 and the period of limitation provided therein must be applied to the exclusion of any in the first Schedule to the Limitation Act. (b) Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act (VI of 1947), Ss. 6, 7 and 8-Analysed-"Irrecoverable" sums, what are Whether S. 6 only prospective and not retrospective-Difference in points of view of Akhlaque Husain, J. and Kayani, J. JUDGMENT AKHLAQUE HUSAIN, J.-This appeal arises out of a suit by the respondent for recovery of Rs. 95,200 in accordance with the provisions contained in the eighth section of the Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act (No. VI) of 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) which came into force on the 15th of April 1947, and expired on the 14th of August 1949. The facts which led to the institution of the suit and are necessary for the disposal of this appeal are quite simple. The defendants are the owners of the Capital Cinema situate in the City of Lahore, which was leased to one Lala Madan Lal by means of a registered deed, dated the 23rd of June 1944, at a monthly rent of Rs. 4,450. The lessee was also to pay the sum of Rs. 30 every month for the water supply. In June 1947, the lessee applied to the Controller under section 4 of the Act to fix the 'fair rent'. By his order dated the 11th, of June 1948, the Controller fixed Rs. 1,500 a month as the fair rent. On appeal the District judge upheld the order, with the modification that he did not treat the amount payable for the water supply as a part of the…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492