Case Details

Citation(s)
1954 SLG 94 1954 SLD 94 1954 PLD 183
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 548 of 1953, decided on 16th December, 1953 from the order of M. A Rahman, Sessions Judge, Sialkot, Ex-officio, Additional Sessions Judge, Jhelum, dated the 11th July, 1953
S. A. RAHMAN AND M.A. SOOFI., JJ
A. M. Khan, for No. 1 at Government expense and accused No. 1 under Police escort and M. B. Zaman, for Nos. 2 and 3, also Ghulam Haider Shah for Appellants. Sh. Zahur Ahmad, for Advocate-General, for
Respondent

ALLI and others

VS

THE CROWN

Law: Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898)

Section: 239

Criminal Procedure Code (V of 9898), S. 239-Joint trial of two sets of Persons, one or the other set of whom was alleged to have committed the murder-Illegal. In order to attract the provisions of section 239, the accused persons must have acted in concert to commit an offence. This section cannot possibly apply to a case in which it is being alleged that either one or the other group of accused persons was guilty of murder and not that they all participated in the murder in collaboration with one another. Joint trial of the two groups was therefore illegal and not merely irregular. The error goes to the root of the case in as much as a statutory provision regarding the mode of trial laid down in the Code was departed from. Such an error does not amount to a mere irregula­rity but involves an illegality which vitiates the trial. Subrahmania Ayyar v. King-Emperor I L R 25 Mad. 61, Azim-ud-Din v. Emperor 14 Cr. L J 563 (S B), Intaj Khan v. Emperor A I R 1934 Rang. (D B) and Nga Sar Kee v. The King A I R 1939 Rang. 390 (D B) ref. The sections are only enabling sections and do not compel a Court to try persons jointly. JUDGMENT RAHMAN, J.-On the evening of the 1st of April 1952, in village Sohawa Diwalian, Police Station Dumman, District Jhelum, one, Chaudhri Khan, son of Allah Ditta, aged about 23, was shot dead with a pistol, outside his house. He expired at the spot. During the night that followed, at about 3 a.m. his younger brother, Muhammad Aslam (P. W. 26). lodged the first information report at Police Station Dumman in which be alleged that the person who shot dead his brother was Muhammad Asghar, son of Fazal Khan, and that be was accompanied at the time of the incident by Sakhi Muhammad, Muhammad Razaq and Allah Ditta. The motive for the offence was said to be the grievance harboured by the accused persons on account of a liaison between the deceased and Mst. Ghulam Sarwar, a niece of Muhammad Asghar accused. Sakhi Muhammad is the husband of this woman. Muhammad Razaq is her brother and Allah Ditta a cousin of Mst. Ghulam Sarwar. According to the informant, Muhammad Asghar had complained to the deceased's father against his misconduct about one and a half…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492