Case Details

Citation(s)
2026 SLG 2513 2026 SLD 2513 = 2026 PLC 526
Islamabad High Court
I.C.A. No.82 of 2025, decided on 1st October, 2025.
Presented By: Inaam Ameen Minhas and Muhammad Asif, JJ
   Munir Ahmed for Appellant.        Faisal Fareed for
Respondent No.1.

FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Chief Information Commissioner, Government of Pakistan and others

VERSUS

MUHAMMAD SAAD ZAMURAD and others

Law: Right of Access to Information Act, 2017

Section: 22(1)(g), 26, 27

Law: Constitution of Pakistan

Section: 199

Right of Access to Information Act (XXXIV of 2017) Ss. 22(1)(g), 26 & 27---Constitution of Pakistan, Art.199---Constitutional petition---Legal standing of petitioner---Contract employee---Ineligible to participate in recruitment proceedings---Respondent / contract employee assailed advertisement issued by appellant / Information Commission for recruitment of lower division clerk---Judge in Chambers of High Court allowed Constitutional petition and directed appellant / Commission to proceed in accordance with law---Validity---Respondent was a contractual employee and was 33 years old, well beyond the minimum age limit of 30 years prescribed in the advertisement---Person who was statutorily ineligible to participate in a process could not suffer any legal injury from the process---Respondent / contract employee by his own ineligibility, placed himself outside the class of individuals who could challenge the recruitment---Constitutional petition was not a bona fide exercise of rights but an attempt to obstruct a lawful process by a person lacking any qualifying right---High Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Art.199 of the Constitution could not entertain petition by a person lacking legal standing---Division Bench of High Court set aside order passed by Judge in Chambers of High Court; resultantly the petition filed by respondent / contract employee was dismissed---Division Bench of High Court directed appellant / Information Commission to complete recruitment process in accordance with ESTA Code and restored the advertisement in question---Division Bench of High Court further directed appellant / Information Commission to frame its Recruitment Rules under the relevant provision of Right of Access to Information Act, 2017---Intra Court Appeal was allowed accordingly.        Federation of Pakistan v. Waqas Mehmood Kayani (Intra Court Appeals Nos. 324/2022 and 326/2022); All Pakistan ZTBL Workers Union v. Federation of Pakistan 2021 PLC 1; Central Board of Revenue Government of Pakistan v. Asad Ahmed Khan PLD 1960 SC 81; Lt. Col. (R) Muhammad Arif Zahid v. Azad Government of the State of Jammu and Kashmir 2018 PLC (C.S.)…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register