| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1954 SLG 80 1954 SLD 80 1954 PLD 265 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 174 of 1952, decided on 11th January, 1954, from the decree of Abdul Samad Khan, Senior Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 1st March, 1952
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Sh. Chiragh Din, for Appellant. Siraj-ud-Din Ahmad, for
Respondents
Second Appeal No. 174 of 1952, decided on 11th January, 1954, from the decree of Abdul Samad Khan, Senior Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 1st March, 1952
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Sh. Chiragh Din, for Appellant. Siraj-ud-Din Ahmad, for
Respondents
Mst. NAUSHA BI
VS
RANGBAZ and others
Law: Court Fees Act, 1870
Section: Schd.1,Art.1,7(v)
(a) Court Fees Act (VII of 1870), Schd. 1, Art. 1-Crossobjeetion-Court fee same as on appeal--"Amount or value of subject, matter -Land assessed to revenue-Amount same as determined under S. 7 (v). According to Article 1 Schedule 1 which governs appeals and cross-objections court-fee is to be paid on the value of the subject-matter but value does not in all cases mean market value. In case of land assessed to revenue value is determined as directed by section 7 (v). (b) Appeal--Time barred-May be treated as cross-objection. (c) Cross appeals in lower appellate Court-Second appeal by defendant alone to which copies of two decrees of the lower appellate Court were attached-Competence. JUDGMENT KAIKAUS, J.-Following are the facts' which give rise to this appeal. One Mehr, a Rajput of village Missa Kaswal, Tahsil Gujarkhan, died childless on the 17th of April 1950. He owned a house as well as occupancy rights in certain lands. Mutation of the land was entered in favour of Nosh a Bi appellant who is his paternal aunt on the basis of a will alleged to have been made in her favour by Mehr. Rangbaz and two others, collaterals of Mehr, filed a suit for possession claiming that they, along with some other persons whom they impleaded as defendants, were entitled to inherit the land as well as the house. The trial Court found that the will was not proved and decreed the suit in respect of that part of the property which was proved to have been occupied by the common ancestor. Nosba Bi as well as the plaintiffs filed appeals against this decree. The appeal of Nosha Bi was dismissed on the ground that it was time-barred. In the appeal which was filed by Rangbaz etc., the learned Senior Civil judge held that inheritance was governed by Muslim Law and not section 59, Tenancy Act, and accepting the appeal be decreed the suit even with respect to that part of the land which was not proved to have- been occupied by the common ancestor. Mst. Nosha Bi has filed the present appeal against the appellate decree. The learned Senior Civil judge who heard the appeal has given two judgments one in each appeal, though in one case it is only a C short judgment, and he has prepared two…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492