Law:

Section:

 Civil Service Rules (Punjab), Vol. I, Part I, rr. 4.13, Note 4 & 10.5(1)-Promotion-Next below rule-Junior Clerk in office of Board of Revenue sent on deputation to another organisation with express guarantee of safeguarding his interests in parent office during deputation period - Such junior clerk getting promotion as stenotypist and stenographer in borrowing organisa tion-Practice of promoting junior clerks as steno typist and then as stenographers after qualifying stenography test-prevailing in Board of revenue-Deputation on reversion to Board of Revenue claiming to be placed above those junior clerk who were junior to him in cadre of junior clerks but had been appointed a steno typist - Held: Keeping in view his deputation tams arid principles of next below rule such junior clerk was entitled to be placed in list of steno typists above those junior Clerks who had been promoted as steno typists because had he remained in parent office he would also have qualified for being appointed as steno typist Plea that he could claim promotion in absentia in his own line i.e. as senior clerk while on deputation, in circumstances, no accepted.   ORDER   S. A. MAHMOOD (CHAIRMAN).-This is an appeal by Rauf Ahmad Bhatti, Stenographer, in the Board of Revenue, Punjab, under section 4 (1) of the West Pakistan Civil Services (Appellate Tribunals) Ordinance, 1969, whereby he prays that he be declared senior as Steno typist in the list of Steno-Typists of Board of Revenue, Punjab, w.e.f. 5th March 1960, and as Stenographer in the list of Stenographers of the Board of revenue, w.e.f. 1-12-1965 and that the order of the learned Member of the Board of Revenue, dated 29-7-1970 be declared to be ultra vires and inoperative qua he rights of the appellant. The appellant in fact claims seniority over respondents 2 to 17 respondents 2 to 8 having become Stenographers and the remaining respondents 9 to 1 7 being Steno typists.                       …