Case Details

Citation(s)
1980 SLG 1599 1980 SLD 1599 = 1980 CLC 1863

Civil Appeals Nos. 46-M. R. and 47-M. R. of 1978, decided on 15th March, 1980.
Chaudhury Rahim Dad Khan, C. J. and Raja Muhammad Khurshid Khan, J

CHIRAGH DIN--Appellant

VERSUS

Mst. DAULAT BIBI--Respondent

Law:

Section:

CHAUDHURY RAHIM DAD KHAN, C. J.--These two appeals, by leave, arise out of two pre-emption suits-one filed by Mst. Daulat Bibi and the other by Mst. Bibi respondent to pre-empt two sales executed by Mst. Sajjada Btbi, their real sister, on 2011-1963, in favour of her husband Chiragh Din. One sale-deed pertains to the transfer of land situate in village Khor while the other relates to the land in village Kotehra Andarlah, Tehsil and District Kotli. The trial Court dismissed both the suits on the ground that the vendee and pre-emptor both were entitled to succession none can claim a superior right of purchase over the other. An appeal taken to the District Judge, Kotli, met the same fate. On second appeal by Mst. Daulat Bibi, the pre-emptor, the High Court was pleased to set aside the judgments of both the Courts below and decreed the suit in favour of the pre-emptor.   2. The only point involved in both these appeals is whether the pre emptor Mst. Daulat Bibi, who is the real sister of cost. Sajjada Bibi and who is also a co-sharer, is clothed with a superior right of purchase as compared with vendee who too, being husband of the vendor, is also a heir under Muslim Law. The trial Court as well as the first appellate Court were of the view that sisters have no superior right as compared with husband while the High Court held that she does fall within section 15, secondly and is, therefore, clothed with superior right to purchase the land in dispute as compared with Chiragh Din, husband of the vendor, who falls under thirdly of clause (b) section 15. The point that requires determination in this case, precisely speaking, is whether Mst. Daulat Bibi, sister of the vendor, has superior right of purchase under section 15 , clause (b), secondly o she too as a sharer under Muhammadan Law has equal right with the vend Chairagh Din who admittedly falls under thirdly of clause (b) section 14 of the Right of Prior Purchase Act. Section 14 of the Right of Prior Purchase Act lays down   "14. Persons in whom right of prior purchase vests in respect of sales of agricultural land and village immovable property.-Subject to the provisions of section 13 the right of…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register