| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1970 SLG 3073 1970 SLD 3073 = 1970 PLD 153 |
Court of Special Judge, Karachi
L. P. A. No. 33 of 1962, decided on 18th June 1959.
Presented By: Qadeeruddin Ahmed and Noorul Arfin, JJ
S. M. Sohail with Abdul Matin for Appellant. Muhammad Halim, Asstt. A.-G. and Sayeed A. Shaikh for
Respondents.
L. P. A. No. 33 of 1962, decided on 18th June 1959.
Presented By: Qadeeruddin Ahmed and Noorul Arfin, JJ
S. M. Sohail with Abdul Matin for Appellant. Muhammad Halim, Asstt. A.-G. and Sayeed A. Shaikh for
Respondents.
Messrs FAQIR SPINNING MILLS LTD. Appellant
VERSUS
GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN AND ANQTHER-Respondents
Law: Arbitration Act (X of 1940)
Section: 4
(a) Arbitration Act (X of 1940)---.4 ward-Prejudice-Award not made rule of Court-Can under certain circumstances cause prejudice to either party thereto. Lutufullah and others v. Muhammad Sidik Sobho Bhati and others A I R 1946 Sind 117 ref. rel. Pushraj Puranmal v. Clive Mills Co. Ltd. A I R 1960 Cal. 180 (b) Arbitration Act (X of 1940), Ss. 30 & 33-Award-Court competent to set aside, adjudge invalid, make it rule of Court, or determine effect of award, even though not filet in Court [Ratanji Virpal & Co. v. Dhirajipal Manilal A I R 1912 Bom. 101 ; Bengal Jute Mills v. Jewraj Heerlal A I K 1944 Cal. 304 ; Bengal Silk Mills Co. Ltd. v. Aisha Ariff A I R 1947 Cal. 106; Lachhmi Prasad v. Gobardhan Das and others A I R 1918 Pat. 171 ; Bajranglal Laduram v. Ganesh Commercial Co. Ltd. A I R 1951 Cal. 78 and A. R. Savkur v. Amritlal Kalidas and others A I R 1954 Bom. 293 dissented from.]. Ratanji Virpal & Co. v. Dhirajipal Mani'al A I R 1942 Bom. 101 ; Bengal Jute Mills v. Jewraj Heerlal A I R 1944 Cal. 304 ; Bengal Silk Mills Co. Ltd. v. Aisha Ariff A I R 1947 Cal. 10 ); Lachhmi Prasad v. Gobardhan Das and others A I R 1948 Pat. 171 ; Bajranglal Laduram v. Ganesh Commercial Co. Ltd. A I R 1951 Cal. 78 and A. R. Savkur v. Amritlal Kalidas and others A I R 1954 Born. 293 dissented from. I. G. H. Arlff and others v. Bengal Silk Mills Ltd. and another A I R 1949 Cal. 350 and John B. Paes v. Soomar A I R 1943 Sind 33 rel. Saha & Co. v. Ishar Singh Kripal Singh & Co. A I R 1956 Cal. 321 ; Bhagwan Radha Kishen v. Commissioner of Income tax A. I R 19$2 All. 856 ; Ganga Ram v. Radha Kishan A I R 1955 Pb. 145 ; Haji Rahemtullah v. Chaudhari Vidya Bhusan A I R 1963 All. 602 ; Mrs. Keays Byrne v. M. Obaidullah Khan P L D 1959 Lab. 146 ; Panchanan Dey v. Union of India A I R 1959 Cal. 84 ; Chhabba Lal's case A I R 1946 P . C 72 ; E. D. Sasson & Co. v. Ramdutt Ramkissen Das A I R 1922 P C 374 ; Ramlal Hargopal v. Kishanchand and others (1923-24) 51 I A 72 ; Chief Kwame Asants v. Chief Kwame Tawin P L D 1949 P C 45; Abdul Hamid v. H. M. Qureshi P L D 1957 S C (Pak.) 145; Tropical Insurance Co. Ltd., New Delhi v. The Superintendent of Insurance…