Case Details

Citation(s)
2003 SLG 899 2003 SLD 899 = 2003 PLC(CS) 439
Supreme Court (AJ&K)
Constitutional Petitions Nos. 220, 232, 251 and 629 of 200(), decided on 21st March, 2002.
Syed Manzoor Hussain Gilani, CJ

IQBAL AHMAD SHAH and others

VERSUS

AZAD GOVERNMENT and 9 others

Law:

Section:

Above captioned Constitutional petitions raise common questions of facts and law hence are heard together and decided through the proposed judgment.   It is alleged by the petitioners that they are appointed as primary teachers on different dates through different orders in Education Department from 1995 to January 30, 1998. Petitions Nos. 220 and 251 relate to appointment of teachers in District Bagh while Petitions Nos.232 and 629 relate to appointments in District Muzaffarabad Azad Kashmir.   The case of the petitioners is that the rules regulating method and qualification for appointment as primary teachers were enforced on 24-9-1989 through which minimum qualification for the post of primary teacher was fixed as Matric with PTC or equivalent. These rules, according the petitioners, were amended through Notification dated 15-7-1990 Whereby it was provided that untrained persons will also be eligible for appointment if trained are not available. The rules were repromulgated by ;mended on 18-5-1994 wherein minimum qualification was provided as Matric 2nd Division with PTC or equivalent qualification. The Rules of 1994 were kept in abeyance through Government Notification dated 14-6-1994 and all appointments including those of the petitioners were made during the period when the rules remained in abeyance. This abeyance notification was withdrawn on 1-1-1998, whereby Rules of 1994 were revived. Another notification was issued by the Government on 22-12-1999 whereby lifting of abeyance of the rules was given effect from 1-2-1998 instead of 1-1-1998. It is stated that in view of above-referred notifications of the Government, requirement of Matric 2nd Division and PTC trained was not in force, hence appointments of non-P.T.Cs. made during the period do not suffer from legal infirmity. The petitioners apprehending their removal from service have filed the above-referred petitions for a writ of prohibition against respondents claiming that as they are appointed. during the period when the rules requiring minimum qualification of primary teacher as matric, or matric Second Division, with PTC were kept in abeyance, their appointments are, therefore, in…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register