Case Details

Citation(s)
2025 SLG 4513 2025 SLD 4513 = 2025 PTD 1313
ANTI-DUMPING APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
Appeal No. 674 of 2025, decided on 17th July, 2025.
Before Mrs. Suraiya Ahmed Butt, Chairman Usman Ahmad Ranjha and Muhammad Saqib Ayyaz, Members
Salman Farooq for Appellants. Azfar Naeem, Senior Legal Advisor for
Respondent No. 1. Saifullah Khan, Ms. Sumaira Kanwal and Rais Mahmood Ali for Private
Respondents. Dates of hearing: 17th, 24th, 30th April, 25th, 26th June, 8th July, 2025

Messrs TAPE TOWN and others

VERSUS

NATIONAL TARIFF COMMISSION and another

Law: Anti-Dumping Duties Act, 2015

Section: 37, 43, 45 & 55, 70(13), 70(1)(ii), 70

 

(a)   Anti-Dumping Duties Act (XIV of 2015)---

----Ss. 45, 55 & 70---Final determination, initiating / carrying of---Appeal challenging Preliminary Determination Notice having already been filed--Objection was that since the impugned Preliminary Determination Notice had now merged into the Final Determination, the present appeal had become infructuous---Validity---It is an admitted position that the preliminary determination dated 31.01.2025 is valid only for a limited period of four months, as stipulated under S. 45 of the Anti-Dumping Duties Act, 2015 ('the Act 2015')---It is also undisputed that the National Tariff Commission ('the Commission') has since issued its final determination dated 24.05.2025 which is currently under challenge in separate appeals before (this) Anti-Dumping Duties Appellate Tribunal, therefore, the present appeal, being entirely premised on the preliminary determination, has become infructuous and no longer raises a live legal issue under the statutory framework, particularly in the light of the conclusive findings and the retroactive effect of the final determination--Appellate Tribunal is not required to adjudicate matters that have ceased to possess legal significance due to subsequent developments within the same proceedings---Appeal, being infructuous, was dismissed, in circumstances.

🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register