Law: University of Karachi Act, (XXVI of 1972)

Section: 23

Law: Constitution of Pakistan, 1973

Section: 199

SUMMARY

Petitioner Dr. Fakhr-ul-Nisa challenged the recommendations of the University of Karachi’s Selection Board, which declined her appointment as Associate Professor in Analytical Chemistry and instead recommended Respondents No. 5 to 8. She argued she was better qualified, possessing a PhD in Analytical Chemistry and a post-doctorate, while the selected candidates had PhDs in Chemistry, not specifically Analytical Chemistry. She also alleged irregularities in the selection process, including the appointment of referees from outside the Analytical Chemistry field and a dissenting note from a Syndicate member.

Respondents (University and selected candidates) argued that:

The selection process followed university rules.