Case Details

Citation(s)
1976 SLG 535 1976 SLD 535 (1976) 105 ITR 472

E.S.D. No. 1 OF 1972 JUNE 17, 1974
SAMBASIVA RAO AND MADHAVA RAO, JJ.
P. Rama Rao for the Applicant. S. Dasaratharama Reddy for the
Respondent.

Controller of Estate Duty

v.

Estate of Late Adapala Krishna Reddy

Law:

Section:

Section 9 of the Estate-Duty Act, 1953 - Gifts within certain period before death - On 11-9-1954, deceased transferred under a sale deed ten acres of land to 'S' - He further executed on 5-9-1957, a gift deed in favour of 'S' in respect of six acres of land - Five years later, deceased changed his mind and executed a settlement deed on 1-12-1962 in respect of aforesaid ten acres of land in favour of 'DS' and his wife - On 21-12-1962 deceased executed a revocation deed cancelling gift dated 5-9-1957 - On 25-12-1962, deceased executed a settlement, deed in respect of aforesaid six acres of land in favour of 'DS' and his wife - 'S' took objection to this and filed a civil suit for permanent injunction restraining defendants including deceased - Finally, a compromise decree was passed by court on 13-1-1963 whereby settlement deed dated 25-12-1962 executed in favour of 'DS' and his wife was agreed to be given effect to - As regards balance ten acres of land, sale deed in favour of 'S' dated 11-9-1954 was confirmed not only by deceased but also by 'DS' and his wife - Subsequently, deceased died on 29-11-1963 - Whether, on aforesaid facts, since 'DS' and his wife got six acres of land only under settlement deed dated 25-12-1962, i.e., within two years before death of deceased, said six acres of land came within scope of section 9 and, thus, was to be included in estate of deceased for purpose of levy of estate duty - Held, yes - Whether so far as remaining 10 acrs of land was concerned, since 'S' had to enjoy said land with possession with absolute rights with effect from 11-9-1954, it had ceased to be part and parcel of deceased's property more than six years before his death, and consequently, no estate duty could be levied thereon - Held, yes FACTS On 11-9-1954, the deceased transferred under a sale deed ten acres of land to 'S'. He further executed on 5-9-1957, a gift deed in favour of the same lady in respect of six acres of land. Five years later, he changed his mind and executed a deed of settlement on 1-12-1962, in respect of the aforesaid ten acres of land, in favour of 'DS', and his wife. In this sale deed, he stated that the sale deed dated 11-9-1954, was a…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492