Case Details

Citation(s)
1954 SLG 136 1954 SLD 136 1954 PLD 24
Lahore High Court
Appeal No. 523 of 1953, decided on 9th October 1953 under section 410, Criminal Procedure Code against the order of Abdul Majid Asghar, Sessions judge, acting as Special Judge at Lahore, dated the 29th June 1953
S. A. RAHMAN, J
Rahim Bakhsh for Appellant. S. A. Mahmud, Assistant Advocate-General for
Respondent

KRISHEN GOPAL BALI

VS

THE CROWN

Law:

Section:

Official Secrets Act (XIX of 1923), S. 3, 13 (6) read with Enemy Agents Ordinance, 1943, S. 14-Appeal from sentence under S. 3 does not lie-Word "trial" in subsection (6) of S, 13 includes appeal. By virtue of the order passed by the Central Government under subsection (6) of section 13 of the Official Secrets Act, by which the procedure prescribed in the Enemy Agents Ordinance became applicable to the case, the right of appeal was lost to the appellant, The meaning of the word "trial" depends on the context in which it appears. It may on some occasions be confined to the proceedings before the original Court that sentences or convicts the accused and on others it may well embrace the proceedings before- an Appellate Court, The word "trial" is an equivocal one and may, in certain contexts, include an appeal. Queen-Empress v. Subbayya I L R (1889) 12 Mad. 451 (D B) : Queen-Empress v. dabanulla I L R (1896) 23 Cal, 975 (D B) ; Re. K. Bali Reddi I L R (1914) 37 Mad. 119 (D B) Dulla v, Crown I L R (1926) 7 Lah. 148 ; Muhammadi Gul Rohilla v. Emperor A I R 1932 Nag. 121 (F B) at page 123 ; In the matter of Madhub Chundar Mozumdar I L R (1889) 16 Cal. 121 ; Bansi Lal v. Emperor 7 Cr. L J 224 and Abdul Khan v. Emperor 37 Cr. L J 707 (D B). ref. JUDGMENT S. A. RAHMAN, J.-Krishan Gopal Bali was sentenced to dour years' rigorous imprisonment under section 3 of the Official Secrets Act„1923 (hereinafter referred to as the Act). He has sought to challenge his conviction and sentence by an appeal to this Court. No copy of the judgment by which the conviction and sentence were recorded against him has been filed with the memorandum of appeal as it is stated that a copy of that order has been refused by the trial Judge. It was prayed that the record of the case may be called for and the appellant's counsel granted a copy of the order impugned so that the appeal could be argued on the merits, A notice was issued to the Crown on this petition of appeal. The conten­tion has been raised on behalf of the Crown that no appeal lies. It appears necessary to make a cursory survey of the provisions of the Act. Section 12 of the Act declares that notwithstanding any­thing in the Code…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492