| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1954 SLG 128 1954 SLD 128 1954 PLD 5 |
Lahore High Court
Regular Second Appeal No. 58 of 1951, decided on 12th March 1953
KAYANI, J
Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan for Appellant. M. Anwar for
Respondent
Regular Second Appeal No. 58 of 1951, decided on 12th March 1953
KAYANI, J
Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan for Appellant. M. Anwar for
Respondent
MUHAMMAD SIDDIQ
VS
THE UNIVERSITY OF THE PANJAB
Law: Universities Act, (VII of 1904)
Section: 3
Law: Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)
Section: 9
(a) Universities Act (VII of 1904), S. 3----"Candidate"---Means person who sits for examination. The word "candidate" has not been defined in the regulations, but it is understood in the present context to mean a person who sits for an examination. (b) Contract-Award of Scholarship by Punjab University -Not Contract. (c) Universities Act (VII of 1904)-Scholarship awarded and declared-Decision can be reviewed by University. There is no express provision for review in "cases where unfair means have been used" but there is no provision against review either. And if in exercising the power of review as though it were an inherent power, the University is not acting contrary to the Acts, Statutes and Regulations constituting it, it is but proper that such power should be recognized. For if it is found, after the declaration of a result, that the award of the highest academic honour has been made to a person who had used unfair means, which means there were no means of detecting at the time, it would indeed be an evil day for the University to find itself important to withdraw the honours. By section 3 of the University Act, University has power to do all acts "which tend to the promotion of study and research", and, on the assumption that unfair means had been used, by the student himself in the one case, by his father in the other, these are eminently cases where the University has acted for the promotion of study and research. The power of scrutinizing cases of this nature, whether before or after the result, inheres in the University and does not involve any excess of jurisdiction. (d) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), S. 9-Conduct of examinations and conduct of students at time of examination--Are fundamental duties of University-Civil Court's jurisdiction ousted. Thomson v. The University of London 1864 L J R XLII 625 ref. (e) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), S. 9-University exceeding statutory powers-Civil Court may interfere. The Civil Court will interfere where the University exceeds its statutory powers is beyond dispute. JUDGMENT KAYANI, J.-These two second appeals, although arising from different facts, relate to the jurisdiction of the University, and…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492