Case Details

Citation(s)
1954 SLG 120 1954 SLD 120 1954 PLD 50
Lahore High Court
Civil Reference No. 5 of 1949, decided on 14th June 1951
MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C, J AND KAYANI, J
Akbar Ali for Petitioners. Muhammad Hussain for
Respondent

MESSRS. BOMBAY CLOTH HOUSE, Lahore

VS

THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, Lahore

Law: Income Tax Act, 1922

Section: 33(2A),33,27

Law: Pakistan (Adaptation of Existing Pakistan Laws) Order, 1947

Section: 9

Law: Limitation Act, 1908

Section: 5

(a) Income Tax Act (XI of 1922), S. 33 (2-A)-Similarity of language between S. 33 and S. 5 of Limitation Act. As to the sufficiency of cause, the language employed in sections 27 and 33 (2-A) of the Income-tax Act and section 5 of the Limitation Act is similar. In both Acts, the provision as to extension of limitation involves the use of discretion. In section 27 of the Income-tax Act there is no room for the exercise of discretion. If the Income-tax Officer is satisfied as to the sufficiency of cause, he must cancel the assessment. In the matter of his satisfaction, he is guided by his own honest intelligence and has no two courses open to him. If his intelligence is at fault, it is matter for appeal, but his finding is undoubtedly one of fact. In the same view, the Appellate Tribunal, when deciding whether there is sufficient cause for delay, is deciding a question of fact. If however, any part of its decision is based on an incorrect appreciation of law, the use of discretion which section 33 (2-A) involves will not be judicial, and a question of law would necessarily arise. Thus, if the Department were misled by instructions from the Central Board of Revenue at Karachi into believing that an appeal could be lodged only on the day when the Appellate Tribunal was notified in the Gazette, and the Tribunal treated this as a sufficient cause for delay, it was not exercising its discretion on a wrong appreciation of law. But the Tribunal having been constituted on the 18th November 1947, and the appeal having been filed on the 25th November, the Tribunal failed to take notice of the established rule of law that the delay of every day after the expiry of limitation should be explained. It is not a sufficient explanation of the delay that the Income-tax Department was asked by its superiors not to institute the appeal until the personnel of the Tribunal should be formally appointed. That the Tribunal itself existed is clear from section 9 of the Pakistan (Adaptation of Existing Pakistan Laws) Order, 1947. The Assistant Registrar on his appointment had been instructed to report himself to the Commissioner of Income-tax and this report had been made by him to the…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492