Case Details

Citation(s)
1953 SLG 92 1953 SLD 92 1953 PLD 45
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 333 of 1950 decided on 25th November 1952, from the decree of Malik Ahmad Khan, District Judge, Attock at Campbellpur, dated the 30th August 1950 affirming with costs, that of Chaudhry Aziz Ahmad, Civil Judge 1st Class, Campbellpur, date
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND B. Z. KAIKAUS, JJ
Jamil Hussain Rizvi for Appellant. M. M. Shafi, on behalf of Sheikh Bashir Ahmad for
Respondent.

GHULAM MUHAMMAD

VS

SULTAN MAHMOOD and others

Law:

Section:

(a) Punjab Relief of Indebtedness Act (VII of 1934),S. 7­---Debt----Mortgagor stipulating that mortgagee was to receive in lieu of interest on part of principal the profits of land mortgaged and the balance of principal was to carry Interest at 1 per cent. per mensem-Mortgagor further stipulating that burden of mortgage money "shall be on my person also"-Held, transaction implied personal liability to pay mortgage money and thus was a "debt". In a mortgage deed for Rs. 1,100 principal, the mortgagor agreed that in lieu of interest on Rs. 800 the mortgagee was to take the profits of the land and the balance of Rs. 300 was to carry interest at Re. 1 percent per mensem and further that "the burden of the liability for the mortgage money shall be on my person". Held, that the latter stipulation imposes in distinct language a personal liability and the mortage deed clearly implied a personal liability to pay the mortgage money. The reason for holding a usufructuary mortgage not to be a debt is that it imports no personal liability. That is the deciding factor. If a mortgage includes a personal liability it is a debt. It does not matter what name we give to such a mortgage. The mortgage, therefore constitutes a debt within the meaning of section 7 of the Punjab Relief Indebtedness Act. Lachhman Singh v. Natha Singh through Harnam Singh and others A I R 1940 Lah. 401 (F B) ref. (b) Punjab Relief of Indebtedness Act (VII of 1934), S. 30­--Suit for redemption covered by section. A suit where the plaintiff asserts that the mortgage has already been paid off and claims possession, is still one for redemption. The question is whether a suit for redemption is a suit in respect of a debt and a decree for redemption a decree in respect of a debt, these being the conditions necessary for the application of section 30 (1). It could not be denied that it is a suit in respect of a mortgage and if the mortgage is a debt it is obvious that the suit is in respect of a debt. Similarly, a decree for redemption is a decree in respect of a mortgage and, therefore, in respect of a debt. To such a case the provisions of section 30 of the Punjab Relief of Indebtedness Act apply. Abdur…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492