Case Details

Citation(s)
1953 SLG 6 1953 SLD 6 1953 PLD 575
Lahore High Court
Civil Reference No. 2 of 1952, decided on 8th December 1952
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN, KAYANI AND KAIKAUS, JJ

Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395

GEOFFREY MANNERS & Co. LTD., OF BOMBAY

VS

GEOFFREY MANNERS & Co. (PAKISTAN) LTD.

Law: Stamp Act, of 1899

Section: 3

Stamp Act (II of 1899), S. 3 and Art. S---Instruments are liable to duty and not transactions---Transaction intended to be sale, but instrument was agreement of sale-Instrument was agreement and not conveyance-Instrument be stamped as agree­ment. The charging section is section 3 and it makes only "instruments" liable to duty, not "transactions". Even if the transaction, therefore, was intended to be a sale, the instrument itself was an agreement of sale, not a conveyance. If a sale-deed had subsequently been executed, it could not be argued logically that with the same contents and conditions the present document should in that event be regarded as an agreement to sell and not a sale because there could not have been two documents about the same transaction. If a deed purports to be an agreement of sale and the law recognises a distinction between such an agreement and an actual sale, the document should be stamped as an agreement and not as a conveyance. Bhola Ram & Sons Ltd. v. The Crown 1934 I L R 15 Lah. 501; In re the Incorporation of Swadeshi Cotton Mills Co., Ltd. A I R 1932 All. 29 and Commissioners of Inland Revenue v. Angus 23 Q B D 589 ref. JUDGMENT KAYANI, J---This is a reference by the Financial Commissioner, Revenue, under section 57 of the Stamp Act, 1899, for a decision by the High Court whether a certain agreement should be stamped under Article 5 of the First Schedule as a mere agreement or under Article 23 as a conveyance. The deed in question purports to have been executed on the 24th of March 1949, between Messrs Geoffery Manners & Co. Ltd. of Bombay, as the vendor company, and Messrs Geoffery Manners 8r Co. (Pakistan) Limited of Lahore as the purchaser company. In para. No. 1 it is stated that "the vendor company shall sell and the purchaser company shall purchase"- (1) the leasehold interest in certain premises, (2) office furniture etc., (3) debts, (4) benefit of all pending contracts etc., (5) cash, bills and notes, and (6) all other property to which the vendor company is entitled in connection with its business in Pakistan. According to para. No. 2 the consideration for the sale shall be such sum as shall be ascertained from…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492