| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2017 SLG 961 2017 SLD 961 2017 PLJ 267 |
Lahore High Court
W.P. No. 28699 of 2015, decided on 23.9.2016. Date ofhearing: 30.6.2016.
SHAMS MEHMOOD MIRZA, JUSTICE
Mr. Tafazzal Haider Rizvi and Anwaar Hussain Janjua, Haider Ali Khan, Advocates for Petitioners.Mr. Asjad Saeed, Ch. Muhammad Nasir and Ms. Samra Malik, Advocates for
Respondent Best Traders.Mr. Sumera Fazil Khan and Humera Fazil Khan, Advocates for H
W.P. No. 28699 of 2015, decided on 23.9.2016. Date ofhearing: 30.6.2016.
SHAMS MEHMOOD MIRZA, JUSTICE
Mr. Tafazzal Haider Rizvi and Anwaar Hussain Janjua, Haider Ali Khan, Advocates for Petitioners.Mr. Asjad Saeed, Ch. Muhammad Nasir and Ms. Samra Malik, Advocates for
Respondent Best Traders.Mr. Sumera Fazil Khan and Humera Fazil Khan, Advocates for H
UNILEVER PAKISTAN FOODS LIMITED - ERVSREGISTRAR TRADE UNIONS AND OTHERS --RespondentS
Law:
Section:
Industrial Relation Acts 2012-- ----Ss. 2(x) & 2(xxxii)--Punjab Industrial Act, 2010, S. 10--Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, Art. 199--Constitutional petition--Registration of union in case of trans-provincial establishment--Cancellation of registered union--Provincial registrar--Jurisdiction--Formation of trade unions of workers of trans-provincial establishment--Validity--Any company employing workmen for purpose of carrying on any business or industry and having its departments and branches in more than one province comes within definition of "trans-provincial"--Petitioner is a company incorporated under Companies Ordinance, 1984 and, therefore, its status as such shall be taken into consideration for purpose of determining whether it is a trans-provincial establishment--Petitioner being a trans-provincial establishment is accordingly governed by IRA, 2012 and unions operating in its various factories, offices and departments shall have to be registered with NIRC--Provincial registrar exceeded his jurisdiction in registering as trade union whereas petitioner being a trans-provincial jurisdiction vested with NIRC under IRA, 2012--Implication being that such members had no right to get themselves registered as a trade union--Other workers unions operating in factory/offices/departments of petitioner were registered with provincial registrar hardly provides any lawful justification for grant of similar status to respondent--Petitioner enjoyed trans-provincial status, controversy regarding law which governs registration of trade union of a trans-provincial establishment does not pose a serious problem--Registrar indeed misconstrued provisions of Factories Act, 1934 in registering union whereas it had no authority under law to do so. Industrial Relations Act, 2012-- ----S. 2(x)--Registration of trade union--Provincial registrar--Jurisdiction--Concurrent legislative list of constitution controlled all matters pertaining to labour disputes, trade unions and all labour laws were promulgated by federation--Promulgated by other provinces--Provincial laws could not deal with issues of labour disputes and trade unions in establishments having presence in more than…