Case Details

Citation(s)
2016 SLG 3452 2016 SLD 3452 2016 CLD 2193
Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan

AKIF SAEED, COMMISSIONER (SCD) AND TAHIR MAHMOOD, COMMISSIONER (CLD)
Rashid Sadiq, CEO RS Corporate Advisory for Appellant. Tariq Hussain, Director (Insurance) and Arif Nizami, Deputy Director (Insurance) for
Respondent (through video conferencing).

EFU GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED

VS

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (INSURANCE) SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN court

Law:

Section:

Insurance Ordinance (XXXIX of 2000)------- --------Ss. 45(5)(b), (6), 59-A & 156-------Failure to maintain proper books and records-------Inspection of record of company-------Failure to give access to Inspection team to various claim files-------During onsite inspection, Inspection team was not given access to various claim files relating to motor claims, which were misplaced allegedly during the shifting of company's corporate branch-------Said files pertained to the workshops, aggregated to more than Rs.1,869,384-------Survey reports of said claims were not available on the Company's Internet Portal-------Fifty four claim files, were missing from the record of the company which raised serious doubts on the authenticity of all those claims/payments-------Said missing of files, signaled inappropriate maintenance of records of the company-------Executive Director (Insurance) of the Commission, dissatisfied with the response of the company, vide impugned order imposed a penalty of Rs.500,000 on the company; with direction to the company to probe into the issue of missing files; and genuineness of claims paid; and to immediately recover the missing files; and report to the Commission within 90 days-------Validity-------Company should have taken care of the files, while shifting premises; and that could not be deemed to be inadvertent on their part-------Fact that, the company, was unable to provide 87% of the requested files, depicted that there had been some level of negligence on part of the company-------All missing files, were related to the workshop owned by close relatives-------Company, could have computerized information of those claims, but it did not contain basis of payment of claims i.e. survey report-------Company, in circumstances, had not complied in terms of S.45(1) of the Insurance Ordinance, 2000-------Default, was committed knowingly in terms of S.156 of the Insurance Ordinance, 2000, as company's stance had been the same throughout-------Was not necessary to provide the original files, as computer records would suffice-------Appellate Bench declined to interfere with impugned order. THIS ORDER PASSED BY: AKIF SAEED, COMMISSIONER…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492