| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1953 SLG 136 1953 SLD 136 1953 PLD 339 |
Lahore High Court
First Appeal No. 46 of 1950 decided on 18th February, 1953, from the decree of the Court of Atta Ullah, Senior Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 24th April, 1950
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND M. R. KAYANI, JJ
Abdul Aziz Khan, Advocate-General and Muhammad Yaqub Ali for Appellant. Mahmood Ali and Rafiq Ahmad for
Respondent
First Appeal No. 46 of 1950 decided on 18th February, 1953, from the decree of the Court of Atta Ullah, Senior Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 24th April, 1950
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND M. R. KAYANI, JJ
Abdul Aziz Khan, Advocate-General and Muhammad Yaqub Ali for Appellant. Mahmood Ali and Rafiq Ahmad for
Respondent
WEST PUNJAB GOVERNMENT
VS
PINDIJHELUM VALLEY TRANSPORT LTD., RAWALPINDI AND SIX others
Law:
Section:
(a) Motor Vehicles Act (IV of 1939),S. 58 (1) (2)-Permits expiring on 27th October, 1942-Permits though renewed for one year were effective for three years--Permits being in force when Ordinance XXVI of 1944 came into force were unaffected by the Ordinance. On their expiry on the 27th October 1942, the permits could be renewed only under section 58 (2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. It is true that subsection (2) does not expressly specify the period for which a permit may be renewed, but it requires that the application for renewal "should he made and disposed of as if it were an application for a permit," This means that the Legislature has made no distinction between issuing and renewing a permit and that the provisions of section 58 (1) as to the period for which a permit may be issued equally apply to renewals. That the Legislature did not intend to leave the matter of duration of renewed permit entirely to the discretion of the Regional Transport Authority is further made clear by a reference to the proviso to section 58 (1) which provides the same period for a permit which is issued for the first time and a permit which is renewed, Therefore, permits though renewed for one year were valid for three years under section 58 (2) read with section 58 (1) and were in force at the time when Ordinance XXVI of 1944 came into operation. They were, therefore, not affected by the Ordinance. (b) Estoppel --Cannot be pleaded against statute, (c) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), S. 9.---Remedy not provided by special Act--Recourse to Civil Court not barred--Motor Vehicles Act (IV of 1939)-Suit for damages for cancellation of permits. The permits of plaintiffs were cancelled by the Provincial Government. The Motor Vehicles Act (IV of 1939), provided no appeal from the order of the Provincial Government. Suit for damages for unlawful cancellation of permits was not barred. Although there is no express provision in the Act which bars the jurisdiction of the civil Court, it must be clear that the duties for the discharge of which the two Transport Authorities were created must be performed by those authorities and by no other person. It would not, for instance, be for the…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492