| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1953 SLG 109 1953 SLD 109 1953 PLD 131 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 238 of 1951, decided on 19th January, 1953, from the decree of Fayyaz Hassan Shah, Esquire, District Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 15th June, 1951, affirming that of Aziz Ahmad, Additional Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 28th August, 1
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan for Appellant. Shaukat Ali Malik for
Respondents.
Second Appeal No. 238 of 1951, decided on 19th January, 1953, from the decree of Fayyaz Hassan Shah, Esquire, District Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 15th June, 1951, affirming that of Aziz Ahmad, Additional Civil Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 28th August, 1
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan for Appellant. Shaukat Ali Malik for
Respondents.
ALAUDDIN
VS
Mst. FARKHANDA AKHTAR
Law:
Section:
(a) Pleadings--Inconsistent allegations of fact-Not permitted---Plaintiff woman denying factum of marriage and in the alternative pleading that whether defendant was married to her or not, being minor, she had repudiated it-Plea, held, not inconsistent. Our law of procedure does place limitations on the power of parties to state facts, the result of which is that though alternative pleas can be taken, such pleas cannot include allegations of facts which would destroy each other. A pleading cannot contain inconsistent allegations of fact. A criterion for finding whether allegations are not would be the answer to the question whether they can or cannot be verified at the same time. If two allegations be such that they cannot both be verified by one and the same person they cannot be allowed to stand and the pleading will be defective. If, However, the allegations be such as can properly be verified at the same time, the pleading cannot be said to suffer from inconsistency. Party is to state only the facts and it is for the Court to apply the law and work out the results, through as a matter of convenience and on account of lack of regard for rules of pleading, such legal effects are generally made parts of pleadings. (b) Muhammadan Law- Marriage-Repudiation by wife---Not necessarily to be formal. In certain circumstances even mere denial of marriage may amount to its repudiation. The only question is whether she is prepared to accept him as a husband or not and if she unequivocally says she is not, the option of puberty is exercised. Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan for Appellant. Shaukat Ali Malik for Respondents. JUDGMENT KAIKAUS, J.---This regular second appeal arises out of suit brought by the plaintiff-respondent on the 4th July 1949 against the defendant-appellant for a declaration that the plaintiff was not married to the appellant and in case the marriage was proved, for its dissolution on the grounds (a) that she had not attained puberty at the time of her alleged marriage and had repudiated the marriage, and (b) that the appellant had not maintained her for more than two years. Parties are refugees from Jullundur. Defendant-appellant pleaded that the parties…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492