SUBJECT: REBUTTAL TO FALSE, MISLEADING AND DEFAMATORY STATEMENTS
ISSUED BY MR. HAROON AHMAD RAFIQ / SLD SYSTEM
Respected Sir,
This response is issued on behalf of Mr. Shahid Sharif and
Shahid Legal Group (SLG) in rebuttal to the statement circulated
by Mr. Haroon Ahmad Rafiq, so called CEO of Super Law Data System
and an IT person, containing allegations against Shahid Legal
Group, its representatives, its business operations, and its
lawful professional activities.
The statement is not a neutral clarification. It is a one-sided
public attack designed to prejudice Shahid Legal Group before
clients, subscribers, and the legal community while the
substantive dispute remains pending before the competent forums.
We categorically reject each unsupported allegation and reserve
all civil, criminal, intellectual-property, and defamation
remedies available under law.
1. Ownership and Rights Are Sub Judice
It is admitted by Haroon Ahmad itself that disputes concerning
ownership, intellectual property, and the use of SLD-related
identifiers are pending before the competent forums, including
Suit No. 29/2026 before the Islamabad Court/IPO forum. Therefore,
Mr. Haroon Ahmad Rafiq cannot treat his own version of facts as
established truth through a public statement.
A party to pending litigation may not convert an unadjudicated
claim into a public accusation of theft, unauthorized copying,
dishonesty, or unlawful business conduct. The proper course is
to plead the case, produce evidence, and allow the Court to
decide. Public statements cannot substitute for pleadings,
affidavits, documentary evidence, or a judicial determination.
Until the competent Court decides the matter, Haroon Ahmad has
no right to present its own ownership claim as conclusive or to
portray Shahid Legal Group as an infringer, successor of copied
material, or a party acting without lawful authority.
2. No Proof of the Allegations Has Been Provided
The statement makes sweeping allegations against Shahid Legal
Group, including alleged copying, unauthorized use, misleading
representations, poor data quality, delayed updates, and
improper financial arrangements. However, it does not identify
or attach:
- The specific SLD material alleged to have been copied;
- The dates, URLs, database entries, judgments, or records said to be infringing;
- Any forensic, technical, or comparative evidence establishing copying;
- Any copyright registration, assignment deed, licence, agreement, or court order in favour of SLD System;
- Any evidence that Shahid Legal Group represented itself as the owner of Super Law Data System;
- Any evidence that SLG claimed that SLD had closed or been transferred;
- Any verified comparison establishing that SLG's database is “two months behind” SLD;
- Any specific erroneous case citation, date, title, reference, or drafting sample attributable to SLG;
- Any evidence connecting Shahid Legal Group with the alleged personal banking arrangements.
Mere assertions, repeated forcefully, are not evidence. If SLD
genuinely possesses proof of infringement or misconduct, it
should place that proof before the competent Court rather than
circulate allegations through public communications.
3. Copyright Does Not Cover Raw Legal Data
The central premise of SLD's allegations is legally flawed.
Under Section 2(3) of the Copyright Ordinance, 1962, copyright
in a compilation of data extends only to the original selection,
arrangement, or compilation, and not to the underlying data or
material itself.
Judgments, statutes, ordinances, rules, notifications, case
citations, and other primary legal materials are public legal
information. Their inclusion in a legal-research database does
not make a database operator the owner of the law, the
judgments, or the underlying information.
Accordingly, SLD cannot claim exclusive ownership over:
- Judgments and orders of courts;
- Statutes, rules, regulations, and notifications;
- Case numbers, citations, dates, party names, and judicial holdings;
- Publicly available legal information;
- The mere fact that two legal-research platforms contain overlapping legal material.
Any claim must be confined to genuinely original elements—such
as original editorial text, proprietary classification systems,
original summaries, distinctive formatting, software code, or
other protectable original expression—and must be proved with
credible evidence.
4. Assignment Requires Written Proof
If SLD alleges that any rights were assigned, transferred, or
licensed to or from any person connected with Shahid Legal
Group, it must produce the written instrument. Section 15 of
the Copyright Ordinance, 1962 provides that no assignment of
copyright is valid unless it is in writing and signed by the
assignor or duly authorized agent.
Likewise, ownership of a business, domain, trademark, database,
or platform is not established by assertions, emails, WhatsApp
messages, or public statements. It is established through
contracts, corporate records, assignment deeds, invoices,
payment records, domain-registration history, trademark
records, and other admissible documentary evidence.
Shahid Legal Group denies any unlawful acquisition, unauthorized
transfer, or unlawful use of SLD System rights, to the extent
such allegations are made. If SLD System claims otherwise, it
should identify the alleged instrument, date, parties, and
terms—and produce it before the Court.
5. The Allegation of “Two Months’ Delay” Is Vague and Unverified
The claim that SLG's data is “approximately two months behind”
is deliberately vague, unverified, and incapable of supporting
the serious allegations made against a professional legal
service.
SLD has not identified:
- The period compared;
- The judgments or updates allegedly missing;
- The source databases used for comparison;
- The methodology of comparison;
- The date of access;
- The specific entries allegedly absent;
- Any evidence that the alleged delay was intentional, systematic, or material.
A generalized claim that a competitor's database is “behind”
cannot justify allegations of professional incompetence,
misleading conduct, or inability to maintain a legal database.
If specific examples exist, they should be disclosed in a
verifiable form, with source links, dates, and side-by-side
comparisons.
6. Alleged Data Errors Are Unsupported
The allegation that SLG's newly added cases contain “incorrect
data entries,” “mistakes in case references,” and “poor
drafting” is generic and unsubstantiated.
No particular case, citation, date, court, judgment title,
paragraph, or alleged error has been identified. Without
particulars, the allegation is a vague attempt to damage SLG's
professional reputation rather than a bona fide quality-control
complaint.
Shahid Legal Group maintains professional standards and
continuously reviews, updates, verifies, indexes, and improves
its legal-research material. Any bona fide error, if specifically
identified, can be examined and corrected through the
appropriate professional and technical process. However,
unsubstantiated allegations of widespread inaccuracy will not
be accepted.
7. Branding and Lawful Competition
SLG denies that its use of its own name, brand, website,
presentation, or business identity constitutes passing off,
infringement, or an attempt to create confusion.
The law protects goodwill against misrepresentation, but it
does not give one legal-research provider a monopoly over the
words “law,” “data,” “system,” legal abbreviations, or ordinary
descriptive terms. The alleged confusion must be proved through
actual marketplace evidence, not assumed from a party's
subjective narrative. The essence of passing off is a
misrepresentation causing the public to believe that one
trader's goods or services are those of another.
Shahid Legal Group operates under its own identity and denies
any representation that it is SLD System, that it owns
SLDSystem.com, or that it is the successor to SLD System,
unless a verified document or authorized communication
expressly supports a different position.
8. Banking and Corporate Allegations Are Irrelevant and Prejudicial
The statement improperly introduces allegations about SLG's
corporate structure, ownership, bank accounts, and receipt of
subscription payments. These allegations are irrelevant to the
alleged intellectual-property dispute and appear calculated to
create suspicion against Shahid Legal Group without evidence.
If SLD System has a genuine concern regarding any financial or
corporate matter, it should identify the specific transaction,
account, entity, date, and alleged irregularity, and pursue the
appropriate legal or regulatory remedy. Public insinuations
about personal bank accounts, without documentary proof, are
unfair and defamatory.
Shahid Legal Group's business, financial, and corporate
arrangements are its own lawful affairs. They do not establish,
disprove, or bear upon the alleged ownership of SLD or any
intellectual-property claim.
9. Defamatory Insinuations Will Not Be Tolerated
The statement contains repeated insinuations that Shahid Legal Group:
- Copied the SLD database;
- Misrepresented ownership or succession;
- Attempted to deceive clients;
- Operates without transparency;
- Lacks the capacity to maintain a legal database;
- Is improperly receiving client payments;
- Is using another party's accumulated work.
These allegations are denied in their entirety. They are
presented without particulars, without documentary proof, and
in a manner calculated to injure the reputation and business
of Shahid Legal Group.
Under the Defamation Ordinance, 2002, truth, good-faith fair
comment on a matter of public interest, and expression of
opinion—as distinct from assertions of fact—are relevant
defences. SLD cannot rely on these defences while making
unparticularized factual allegations of copying, dishonesty,
and financial impropriety.
10. Demand for Cessation and Correction
Shahid Legal Group calls upon Mr. Haroon Ahmad Rafiq and SLD System to:
- Immediately cease circulating false, misleading, defamatory, and unsubstantiated statements against Shahid Sharif and Shahid Legal Group.
- Withdraw and correct the impugned statement, communications, advertisements, and website content to the extent they attribute ownership claims, copying, misconduct, or financial irregularity to SLG without proof.
- Refrain from representing that the ownership dispute has been decided, or that SLG's rights have been judicially determined, when the matter remains pending.
- Provide particulars and documentary evidence for every specific allegation, through the proper legal forum rather than public circulation.
- Confine all substantive disputes to the pending proceedings and abide by the Court's process.
11. Reservation of Rights
Shahid Legal Group fully reserves its right to:
- File a detailed written statement, rejoinder, application, or counterclaim as legally advised;
- Seek appropriate injunctive and declaratory relief;
- Initiate proceedings for defamation, malicious prosecution, abuse of process, and unlawful interference with business, where legally available and appropriate;
- Seek costs, damages, and other remedies under applicable law;
- Place on record all evidence demonstrating the falsity, malice, and prejudicial nature of the impugned statements.
This response is issued without prejudice to SLG's rights and
remedies. Nothing stated herein shall be construed as an
admission of any allegation made by Haroon Ahmad.
Yours faithfully,
Shahid Sharif
Shahid Legal Group
sldsystempk.com
Shahid Law Data System
This statement is published as supplied by the client. Its legal
accuracy and approval for public release should be confirmed by
the client's legal counsel.