"\u003chtml xmlns:o=\"urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office\"\r\nxmlns:w=\"urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:word\"\r\nxmlns=\"http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40\"\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003chead\u003e\r\n\u003cmeta http-equiv=Content-Type content=\"text/html; charset=windows-1252\"\u003e\r\n\u003cmeta name=ProgId content=Word.Document\u003e\r\n\u003cmeta name=Generator content=\"Microsoft Word 9\"\u003e\r\n\u003cmeta name=Originator content=\"Microsoft Word 9\"\u003e\r\n\u003clink rel=File-List href=\"./1996J1_files/filelist.xml\"\u003e\r\n\u003ctitle\u003eDISSOLUTION OF CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY OF PAKISTAN\u003c/title\u003e\r\n\u003c!--[if gte mso 9]\u003e\u003cxml\u003e\r\n \u003co:DocumentProperties\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Author\u003eSyed Aleem Muzaffar\u003c/o:Author\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Template\u003eNormal\u003c/o:Template\u003e\r\n  \u003co:LastAuthor\u003eSaif\u003c/o:LastAuthor\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Revision\u003e4\u003c/o:Revision\u003e\r\n  \u003co:TotalTime\u003e1\u003c/o:TotalTime\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Created\u003e2002-04-11T05:44:00Z\u003c/o:Created\u003e\r\n  \u003co:LastSaved\u003e2003-01-03T07:00:00Z\u003c/o:LastSaved\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Pages\u003e4\u003c/o:Pages\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Words\u003e1847\u003c/o:Words\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Characters\u003e10531\u003c/o:Characters\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Company\u003eORATIER\u003c/o:Company\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Lines\u003e87\u003c/o:Lines\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Paragraphs\u003e21\u003c/o:Paragraphs\u003e\r\n  \u003co:CharactersWithSpaces\u003e12932\u003c/o:CharactersWithSpaces\u003e\r\n  \u003co:Version\u003e9.2720\u003c/o:Version\u003e\r\n \u003c/o:DocumentProperties\u003e\r\n\u003c/xml\u003e\u003c![endif]--\u003e\u003c!--[if gte mso 9]\u003e\u003cxml\u003e\r\n \u003cw:WordDocument\u003e\r\n  \u003cw:View\u003eNormal\u003c/w:View\u003e\r\n  \u003cw:DrawingGridHorizontalSpacing\u003e2.85 pt\u003c/w:DrawingGridHorizontalSpacing\u003e\r\n  \u003cw:DisplayVerticalDrawingGridEvery\u003e2\u003c/w:DisplayVerticalDrawingGridEvery\u003e\r\n \u003c/w:WordDocument\u003e\r\n\u003c/xml\u003e\u003c![endif]--\u003e\r\n\u003cstyle\u003e\r\n\u003c!--\r\n /* Style Definitions */\r\np.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal\r\n\t{mso-style-parent:\"\";\r\n\tmargin:0in;\r\n\tmargin-bottom:.0001pt;\r\n\tmso-pagination:widow-orphan;\r\n\tfont-size:12.0pt;\r\n\tfont-family:\"Times New Roman\";\r\n\tmso-fareast-font-family:\"Times New Roman\";}\r\nh1\r\n\t{mso-style-next:Normal;\r\n\tmargin-top:0in;\r\n\tmargin-right:127.45pt;\r\n\tmargin-bottom:0in;\r\n\tmargin-left:0in;\r\n\tmargin-bottom:.0001pt;\r\n\ttext-align:justify;\r\n\tmso-pagination:widow-orphan;\r\n\tpage-break-after:avoid;\r\n\tmso-outline-level:1;\r\n\tfont-size:12.0pt;\r\n\tfont-family:\"Times New Roman\";\r\n\tmso-font-kerning:0pt;\r\n\tmso-ansi-language:EN-GB;}\r\n@page Section1\r\n\t{size:6.35in 841.7pt;\r\n\tmargin:.75in 0in 2.9pt .35in;\r\n\tmso-header-margin:.5in;\r\n\tmso-footer-margin:.5in;\r\n\tmso-paper-source:0;}\r\ndiv.Section1\r\n\t{page:Section1;}\r\n--\u003e\r\n\u003c/style\u003e\r\n\r\n\r\n \r\n\r\n\u003cbody lang=EN-US style=\u0027tab-interval:.5in\u0027\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cdiv class=Section1\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003ch1 style=\u0027margin-right:0in\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\u003eDISSOLUTION OF CONSTITUENT\r\nASSEMBLY OF PAKISTAN\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eAND\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eTHE LEGAL BATTLES OF MOULVI TAMIZUDDIN KHAN\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eBy\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eSyed Sharifuddin Pirzada,\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eSenior Advocate\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eThe dark night of 23rd October, 1954 has been\r\ndescribed as the Night of the Generals. The Prime Minister, Muhammad Ali Bogra\r\nreturned from his foreign tour and drove straight to the Governor\u0026#8209;General\r\nHouse with a General to his right and a General to his left and was forced to\r\nagree to a proclamation dissolving the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan. The\r\ndawn of 24th October witnessed the demise of the sovereign democratic set, up.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eThe case of Moulvi Tamizuddin Khan v. The\r\nFederation of Pakistan and others filed in Chief Court of Sindh in November,\r\n1954 challenging the validity of the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly of\r\nPakistan by the Governor\u0026#8209;General is undoubtedly a causea celebre. In view\r\nof the attempts of the authorities and their agencies to prevent the\r\npresentation of the writ petition, Moulvi Tamizuddin Khan reached the Court in\r\na rickshaw through the side gate clad in burqa. His lawyers were threatened\r\nwith arrests. I narrowly escaped from the car accident which seemed to be an\r\nattempt on my life. The Intelligence personnel tried to snatch the petition but\r\nthe timely action of Mr. Roshan Ali Shah, the Registrar of the Sindh Chief\r\nCourt, saved the situation. Sir George Constatine the Chief Justice threatened\r\nto take contempt action. The leading counsel Mr. D.N. Pritt had to be contacted\r\nconfidentially and messages were exchanged in codes as if between the physician\r\nand the patient. Its brief account is found in the memories of Mr. Pritt\r\nentitled, `The Defence Accuses\u0027. The unanimous decision of the Sindh Chief\r\nCourt in declaring the dissolution as unconstitutional and restoring the\r\nConstituent Assembly and its President reflected the independence of judiciary\r\nand was indeed bold. In the appeal filed by the Government before the Federal\r\nCourt, there were acrimonious encounters between Chief Justice Munir and Mr. I.\r\nI. Chundrigar, Senior Counsel of Tamizuddin Khan. The Government suppressed the\r\nfile containing the views of the Quaid\u0026#8209;i\u0026#8209;Azam that the Constituent\r\nAssembly was a sovereign body and the laws enacted by it did not require the\r\nassent. The rules adopted by the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan in this\r\nbehalf in May, 1948 were followed by the Indian Constituent Assembly in\r\nNovember, 1948. The Indian Supreme Court felt no hesitation in holding that no\r\nassent was required to the legislation passed by the Constituent Assembly as it\r\nwas a sovereign body. However, the Appeal of the Government was allowed by\r\nMunir, C.J. in an abrupt manner on technical grounds. The writs of mandamus and\r\nquo warranto issued by the Sindh Chief Court were set aside on the ground that\r\nsection 223\u0026#8209;A of the Government of India Act which conferred powers of\r\nwrits was invalid as it had not received the assent of the Governor\u0026#8209;General.\r\nMr. Justice A.R. Cornelius gave a dissenting judgment. When the Reference made\r\nby the Governor\u0026#8209;General was being heard, it was submitted on behalf of\r\nMoulvi Tamizuddin that the facts mentioned therein were incorrect and\r\nmisleading and that an opportunity be afforded to controvert the same by an\r\naffidavit. Munir, C.J. declined. That evening Moulvi Tamizuddin Khan and his\r\ncounsel took the decision to withdraw from the proceedings. Unfortunately, late\r\nin the night, the Junior Advocate of Moulvi Sahib happened to spot Mr. Mirza,\r\nthe Registrar of the Federal Court, in the lobby of the Falleties Hotel and\r\nindiscreetly talked about the withdrawal from the proceedings. The Registrar\r\nalerted Munir, C.J. Next day when the Court resumed the hearings, the learned\r\nChief Justice announced that Moulvi Tamizuddin could file his affidavit. This\r\nmisled Moulvi Sahib. The affidavit and draft Constitution prepared by the\r\nConstituent Assembly were accordingly filed in the Federal Court. However in\r\nthe opinion given by Munir, C.J. it was stated that in view of the advisory\r\njurisdiction, the Court was to give the opinion on the basis of the facts\r\nstated by the Governor\u0026#8209;General in the reference. Unfortunately, the\r\naffidavit of Moulvi Tamizuddin was not taken into consideration.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eOne of the main points involved was the effect\r\nof the Indian Independence Act, 1947. The said Act marked the end of British\r\nrule in the Sub\u0026#8209;Continent and India and Pakistan secured independence.\r\nThe British transferred power to the two independent dominions which decided to\r\nremain in the Commonwealth. When the Indian Independence Bill was under\r\ndiscussion between Labour and Conservative Leaders, Churchill objected to its\r\ntitle. The stand taken by him about the dominions status is somewhat similar to\r\nthe views expressed by Chief Justice Munir. The British Prime Minister, Attlee,\r\nreplied to the points raised by him and his contentions concur with the\r\nconclusions reached by Chief Justice Cornelius. Be that as it may, Quaid\u0026#8209;i\u0026#8209;Jinnah\r\nwas consistent throughout. Recently, a letter has been traced, which as written\r\nby Mr. Jinnah as early as 7th September, 1929 to Mr. Ramsay MacDonald the then\r\nBritish Prime Minister, wherein it was stated\u0026#8209;\u0026#8209;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u0026quot;What we have to convince the different\r\nparts of the Empire is that the British Commonwealth of Nations does not mean\r\nonly European races but of Dominions of His Majesty\u0027s Government wherever\r\nsituated and the whatever nationality caste creed or colour they may be. \u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(L/PO/101. India Office Library)\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eIf the British and the Congress (Gandhijee and\r\nNehrus) had responded to Mr Jinnah\u0027s call, the Sub\u0026#8209;Continent would have\r\nattained dominion status in or about 1930\u0026#8209;1931.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eDuring the pendency of proceedings in the Sindh\r\nChief Court and again to its title in the Federal Court attempts were made for\r\ncompromise formula but Ghulam Muhammad (the Governor\u0026#8209;General) was\r\nadamant. When the Sindh Chief Court was about to announce the judgment, in\r\naccordance with the instruction of Muhammad Ali Bogra (the Prime Minister). The\r\nemissaries (Inamullah Khan and Muhammad Ali Rangoonwala) carried the letter of\r\nthe Senior Minister Dr. AM Malik to advise the Queen to recall the Governor\u0026#8209;General.\r\nUnfortunately Muhammad Ali Bogra could not act in time.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eWhen the matter was pending in the Sindh Chief\r\nCourt, the Governor\u0026#8209;General sent Justice Shahabuddin. Senior Judge of the\r\nFederal Court, to East Pakistan to act as the Governor. His absence from the\r\nBench during the hearing of the Appeal and the Reference materially affected\r\nthe decisions. Be that as it may, the dissent of Justice Cornelius is monumental.\r\nCharless Evans Huges says. \u0026quot;A dissent in a Court of last resort is an\r\nappeal to the brodding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day\r\nwhen a later decision may possibly correct the error into which the dissenting\r\nJudge believes the Court to have been betrayed\u0026quot;. Justice Krishna Iver\r\nwrites \u0026quot;Dissent when deliberately rested on principle is often a sign of\r\ndemocratic health\u0026quot;.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eMuhammad Munir after his retirement as Chief\r\nJustice of Pakistan frankly conceded. \u0027The mental anguish caused to the Judges\r\nby these cases is beyond description. At moments like these public law is not\r\nto be found in the books. It lies elsewhere. \u0026quot;Stanley de Smith commented\r\n\u0026quot;It is clear that the leading decision in 1955 was not a very well\u0026#8209;disguised\r\nact of political judgment. By the normal canons of construction what the\r\nGovernor\u0026#8209;General had done was null and void.\u0026quot; Justice Yaqub Ali,\r\nformer Chief Justice of Pakistan opined \u0026quot;The judgments in the case of\r\nMoulvi Tamizuddin Khan, Governor\u0026#8209;General\u0027s Reference 1 of 1955 and the\r\nState v Dosso had profound effect on the Constitutional development in\r\nPakistan. As a commentator has remarked, a perfectly good country was made into\r\na laughing stock\u0027.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003ch1 style=\u0027margin-right:0in\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\u003eMR D.N. PRITT S RECOLLECTIONS\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eMr. D.N. Pritt has referred to the circumstances\r\nin which he was engaged, in his Memoirs, Volume III, \u0026quot;The defence\r\naccuses\u0026quot;. To quote his own words. \u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003ch1 style=\u0027margin-right:0in\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\u003e CONSTITUTIONAL CASE \u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eThen, in 1954, I had another case in Pakistan.\r\nThe Government had assumed\u003cspan style=\"mso-spacerun: yes\"\u003e  \u003c/span\u003epower to\r\ndissolve the Constituent Assembly, and the speaker and some other\u003cspan\r\nstyle=\"mso-spacerun: yes\"\u003e  \u003c/span\u003emembers challenged this in the Courts, and\r\nemployed me to appear for them. I was in Singapore at the time, and, thinking\r\nit unsafe to communicate with me by letter or cable, they sent one of their\r\nnumber of Singapore to talk to me. I agreed to do the case if it should prove\r\npossible, and we arranged, as a modest disguise for further cables, that I was\r\na surgeon who might be required for a difficult operation in Karachi. Further\r\ntalk took place in Colombo and I accepted the case, and arrived in Karachi by\r\nair, with my wife. My clients, fearing that I might be excluded from Pakistan\r\nby the Government if it realised why I was coming, did not meet us at the\r\nairport: we accordingly took the omnibus into Karachi, and got in touch with\r\nthem there. We set about the arduous work of preparing arguments. I had an\r\nadmirable junior, Syed Sharifuddin. I was not a \u0027a member of any Bar in\r\nPakistan: on my previous visit mentioned above, I had been welcomed by the\r\nCourt, and told that it would be very happy to hear me without bothering about\r\nqualifications: this time, as it was a matter of appearing before what had been\r\nthe Chief Court of\u003cspan style=\"mso-spacerun: yes\"\u003e  \u003c/span\u003eSindh, the\r\npermission of the Court had to be obtained, and this was done without\r\ndifficulty.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eOur claim was for an order under what is called\r\n`Writ Procedure\u0027 in India and Pakistan, and `Crown practice\u0027 in England,\r\ndeclaring that the assembly had not been validly dissolved. This procedure,\r\nwhich works relatively quickly, was obviously the correct one, but the Government,\r\nin addition to arguing that we were not entitled in law to the declaration for\r\nwhich we asked, also argued that Writ procedure was not appropriate. It was\r\nabsurd that a Government, challenged as to the validity of its action, which\r\nmust obviously be determined on its merits sooner or later, should attempt to\r\nwin on a point which would not decide the substance of the matter, and thus\r\nleave the whole Constitutional position of the country in suspense.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eA little to my surprise, after long arguments\r\nand some impression of division of opinion among the Judges, we obtained a\r\nunanimous judgment from the Sindh Chief Court in our favour both on the\r\nquestion of procedure and on merit.\u0026quot;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003ch1 style=\u0027margin-right:0in\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\u003eKANGA AND ENGINEER\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/h1\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eShortly thereafter I proceeded to Bombay and\r\nconsulted Sir Jamshedji Kanga and Sir N.P. Engineer. On or about 28th November,\r\n1954, we held consultations for about four hours. On 30th November 1954, they\r\ngave their opinion and their conclusions were:\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(1) The Governor\u0026#8209;General had no power to\r\ndissolve the Constituent Assembly as Governor\u0026#8209;General and that the\r\nProclamation is ultra vires of his authority and is void and of no effect;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(2) That even before the Independence Act there\r\nwas no prerogative in His Majesty to dissolve the Indian Legislature.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(3) That even if His Majesty had such a\r\nprerogative before the enactment of the Indian Independence Act, such\r\nprerogative ceased to exist after the Indian Independence Act came into force;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(4) That even if such a prerogative existed\r\nafter the Independence Act came into force, the power to exercise such\r\nprerogative has not been delegated or conferred on the Governor\u0026#8209;General;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(5) That in any event the Governor\u0026#8209;General\r\nhas not purported to exercise this power on behalf of her Majesty and the\r\nproclamation is not in the name of her Majesty;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e(6) As regards the prayer for a writ of quo\r\nwarranto, in our opinion, the appointment of the Ministers purported to have\r\nbeen made by the Notification, dated 25th October, 1954 is invalid. The\r\nMinisters who were functioning until the Proclamation of dissolution was issued\r\nhad not resigned. It can hardly be suggested that they were dismissed by the\r\nProclamation in question. If that were so then the 3 Ministers now functioning\r\nincluding the Prime Minister should have been reappointed. That, however, was\r\nnot done. In our opinion the appointment of the new Ministers is invalid.\u0026quot;\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eMr. I.I. Chundrigar, myself and other Pakistani\r\ncounsel did not charge any fees. Mr. D.N. Pritt took token fees which were paid\r\nby Mr. Roshanali Bhimjee. In the Reference, Munir, C. J. ordered the Government\r\nto pay a sum of Rs.10,000 to Mr. D.N. Pritt. The legal battles of Moulvi Sahib\r\nhave a place of their own in the Constitutional and legal history of Pakistan.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003eIn this volume apart from the pleadings,\r\nsummary of arguments have also been given. The said summary is based on my\r\nnotes. I have also consulted the available reports of proceedings of some of\r\nthe hearings of Sindh Chief Court as well as the Appeal in the Federal Court, which\r\nwere prepared for the use of the Advocate\u0026#8209;General. The proceedings as\r\npublished in the `Dawn\u0027 and the `Pakistan Times\u0027 proved helpful.\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003cp class=MsoNormal style=\u0027text-align:justify\u0027\u003e\u003cb\u003e\u003cspan lang=EN-GB\r\nstyle=\u0027mso-ansi-language:EN-GB\u0027\u003e\u003c![if !supportEmptyParas]\u003e\u0026nbsp;\u003c![endif]\u003e\u003co:p\u003e\u003c/o:p\u003e\u003c/span\u003e\u003c/b\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003c/div\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003c/body\u003e\r\n\r\n\u003c/html\u003e\r\n"